Bitcoin Core’s Evolution: Version 28 and the Road Ahead

Briefing Notes

My 'briefing notes' summarize the content of podcast episodes; they do not reflect my own views. If you have comments about this briefing note, please leave a comment below (requires signing up for a free blog subscription). Note that some of the podcast episodes I summarize may be sponsored: don't trust, verify, if the information you are looking for is to be used for decision-making.

Summary

The October 3, 2024 episode of the Stephan Livera Podcast featured an interview with Gloria Zhao and Fabian Jahr about Bitcoin Core’s upcoming Version 28 release. The conversation highlighted major improvements like Assume UTXO, which accelerates node synchronization, and Package Relay, designed to optimize transaction fees for the Lightning Network. The episode also addressed challenges in Bitcoin Core’s decentralized development model and the balance between innovation, security, and scalability.

Take-Home Messages

1. Assume UTXO revolutionizes Bitcoin node synchronization by allowing users to start their nodes quickly, significantly reducing sync time while maintaining background validation.
2. Package Relay enhances transaction efficiency in the Lightning Network, lowering costs for participants and improving the overall user experience during periods of fee volatility.
3. Testnet 4 reset offers a robust testing environment for developers, ensuring that future updates to Bitcoin Core are thoroughly vetted before being implemented on the mainnet.
4. The decentralized development process is slow but secure, with a strong emphasis on reviewing code meticulously to ensure high security standards.
5. Collaboration within the open-source community is critical for pushing key Bitcoin Core projects forward, highlighting the importance of communication and shared effort.

Overview

In the October 2, 2024 episode, Zhao and Jahr discuss Bitcoin Core Version 28, focusing on features such as Assume UTXO and Package Relay. Assume UTXO is an important improvement for node operators, allowing them to begin using their Bitcoin nodes almost immediately without waiting for full blockchain synchronization. This update is expected to lower the barrier to running full nodes, encouraging greater decentralization.

Package Relay is another significant update, particularly beneficial for Lightning Network users. It optimizes transaction fee management by reducing the need for high overestimation during periods of fee volatility. This feature improves the efficiency and affordability of transactions, making the Lightning Network more accessible for micropayments.

The episode also explored the reset of Testnet 4, which provides developers with an environment to test new features without impacting the mainnet. This reset is a crucial step for ensuring that Bitcoin Core’s upgrades can be rigorously tested in a safe setting, reducing the risk of bugs or security issues affecting live transactions.

Despite the exciting updates, Zhao and Jahr emphasized the challenges of Bitcoin Core’s decentralized development model. Projects like Assume UTXO often take years to materialize, partly due to the lack of a central decision-making authority. This decentralized approach, while slow, ensures that Bitcoin’s security remains a top priority.

Stakeholder Perspectives

• Developers: Prioritize security and thorough review, working collaboratively to ensure new features are safe and efficient before they are implemented. The decentralized nature of Bitcoin development allows for more voices but often delays critical upgrades.
• Node Operators: Will benefit from Assume UTXO as it significantly reduces the time required to synchronize a full node. This could encourage more individuals to run full nodes, promoting greater network decentralization.
• Lightning Network Users: Stand to gain from the improvements in Package Relay, which reduces transaction fees and makes fee management during congestion more predictable and affordable.
• Investors: Can view these updates as positive steps toward making Bitcoin more scalable and decentralized, which will be important for long-term adoption and network resilience.

Implications

The introduction of Assume UTXO and Package Relay in Bitcoin Core Version 28 reflects Bitcoin’s ongoing efforts to balance scalability with decentralization. Assume UTXO offers a faster synchronization process that will likely increase the number of full nodes running on the network, contributing to better decentralization and security. Package Relay will make running a Lightning Network node more affordable, encouraging wider participation in Bitcoin’s Layer 2 solution, which is crucial for scalability.

However, the decentralized development process poses challenges. With no central authority, important updates like Assume UTXO can take years to gain traction, leading to missed opportunities for quicker innovation. To maintain Bitcoin’s competitive edge in the rapidly evolving blockchain landscape, it is important for the community to explore ways of improving collaboration and prioritization within the development process, without sacrificing security.

Future Outlook

The Bitcoin Core development team will continue to focus on enhancing scalability, security, and decentralization. Assume UTXO and Package Relay represent incremental but significant steps in this direction. The improvements in node synchronization and transaction efficiency are vital for supporting Bitcoin’s long-term growth, especially as more users and institutions engage with the network.

Despite the slow pace of decentralized development, Bitcoin’s commitment to security and resilience remains paramount. The community will need to work together to ensure future updates are implemented more efficiently while maintaining the stringent standards that have become synonymous with Bitcoin Core. Key areas of focus in the coming years will likely include further scalability enhancements and improvements to transaction efficiency, particularly in Layer 2 solutions like the Lightning Network.

Information Gaps

• What mechanisms can be introduced to speed up the decentralized development process without compromising security and code quality? Speeding up the decentralized development process is crucial for ensuring Bitcoin’s ability to innovate. Research into more efficient collaboration models or decision-making processes could help reduce the time it takes to implement critical features while retaining Bitcoin's security standards.
• How can Assume UTXO be expanded to improve Bitcoin's scalability and encourage more users to run their own nodes? Further exploration of the scalability potential of Assume UTXO is necessary to understand how it can be optimized and adapted to encourage a larger number of users to run full nodes, thereby increasing network decentralization.
• What security risks arise from the increased reliance on automated fee bumping in Lightning, and how can these risks be mitigated? The risks introduced by automated fee bumping during fee spikes must be carefully examined to ensure they do not undermine the long-term stability and security of the Lightning Network.
• How can Bitcoin Core ensure compatibility across different Bitcoin node implementations, especially with competing protocols like BTCd? Compatibility across different node implementations is essential for preventing fragmentation in the Bitcoin network. Research into mechanisms that ensure interoperability between various Bitcoin node versions is needed to maintain network cohesion.
• What are the most effective ways to mitigate the risks associated with trusting UTXO sets during initial node syncs without losing speed benefits? Research into minimizing the risks associated with Assume UTXO’s trust model is important to ensure that node operators can enjoy faster syncs without compromising the security and integrity of their transactions.

Broader Implications

Bitcoin Node Decentralization and Security

Assume UTXO can significantly boost node decentralization by reducing synchronization time, encouraging more users to run their own nodes. This improvement strengthens Bitcoin’s censorship resistance but introduces short-term trust in UTXO data, which needs careful management. Future work should focus on minimizing trust dependencies while maintaining speed advantages.

Long-Term Scalability Challenges

Assume UTXO and Package Relay are valuable for improving node performance and transaction efficiency but only address incremental scalability issues. The broader challenge of handling increased transaction volumes remains unresolved, especially at the base layer. Enhancing Layer 2 solutions like the Lightning Network will be critical for Bitcoin’s long-term scalability and adoption.

Implications for Institutional Adoption

The updates in Version 28, especially Assume UTXO and Package Relay, could lower technical barriers for institutions and encourage broader use of Bitcoin. Faster node synchronization and reduced transaction fees improve operational efficiency, making Bitcoin more attractive for institutional integration. However, the slower pace of Bitcoin’s decentralized development may limit its appeal for risk-averse businesses.

Policy and Regulatory Implications

Assume UTXO's reliance on trust during synchronization might prompt regulatory scrutiny over potential vulnerabilities in node operation. As Bitcoin’s transaction efficiency improves, particularly through Lightning, regulators may impose stricter KYC/AML requirements on payment platforms. Bitcoin’s growing role in global remittances could lead to increased policy focus on cross-border financial regulations.