Portfolio diversification benefits of alternative currency investment in Bitcoin and foreign exchange markets.
Full article summary: Qarni, M.O., Gulzar, S., 2021. Portfolio diversification benefits of alternative currency investment in Bitcoin and foreign exchange markets. Financial Innovation 7, 17.
This article summary is part of my personal background research work. The top part of each post had a detailed summary of the article. Scroll farther down the page for the article's broader implications for Bitcoin.
(1) Article Summary
Link
Muhammad Owais Qarni
Keywords
- Bitcoin market volatility
- Portfolio diversification
- Foreign exchange markets
- Spillover index
- Asymmetric volatility
- Frequency connectedness
- Alternative currency trading
- Risk minimization
- Major trading currencies
- Volatility spillover dynamics
Short summary
This study investigates the portfolio diversification benefits of Bitcoin when traded in foreign exchange markets alongside six major currencies: the US dollar, euro, Japanese yen, British pound sterling, Australian dollar, and Canadian dollar. The research explores how Bitcoin's detachment from traditional economic fundamentals allows it to serve as a robust diversification tool in investment portfolios, especially during financial downturns. The authors employ a series of advanced econometric methods, including the spillover index, spillover asymmetry measures, and frequency connectedness, to analyze volatility spillover between Bitcoin and these currency pairs over the period from September 2014 to December 2018.
The results indicate a generally low level of integration between Bitcoin and these traditional currencies, with Bitcoin providing significant diversification benefits, particularly when traded against the euro. The study finds that the volatility spillover is more pronounced at short horizons and that Bitcoin's hedging capabilities differ across currencies, acting as a hedge for the euro, Swiss franc, and British pound sterling, while serving as a diversifier for other currencies. These findings suggest that including Bitcoin in a portfolio can enhance returns and reduce risks, making it a valuable asset for investors and policymakers looking to optimize their strategies in increasingly volatile markets.
Methodology
The study utilizes three key econometric methodologies to assess the spillover effects and diversification benefits of Bitcoin in foreign exchange markets:
- Spillover Index (Diebold and Yilmaz 2012): This method is used to measure the average static and dynamic volatility spillover between Bitcoin markets and the foreign exchange pairs of six major trading currencies. The index captures the degree of interconnectedness by quantifying how shocks in one market impact others, providing insights into the directional and pairwise spillover effects.
- Spillover Asymmetry Measures (Barunik et al. 2017): These measures extend the spillover index by decomposing volatility into positive and negative components, allowing the study to assess whether positive or negative shocks have different impacts on market spillovers. This asymmetry provides a deeper understanding of how different types of volatility interact across markets.
- Frequency Connectedness (Barunik and Křehlík 2018): This approach analyzes the spillover effects across different time horizons, distinguishing between short- and long-term spillovers. The method provides insights into how quickly markets react to shocks and how these reactions evolve over time, revealing the dynamic nature of market integration.
These methodologies are applied to a dataset spanning from September 2014 to December 2018, covering daily observations of Bitcoin prices and foreign exchange rates for six major currencies.
Results
Volatility Spillover: The average volatility spillover between Bitcoin markets and foreign exchange pairs is found to be 58.3%. The study reveals that Bitcoin markets exhibit significant intra-market volatility spillover, with minimal influence on and from foreign exchange pairs. Notably, the euro-denominated Bitcoin market (EUR) is the most isolated, showing the least vulnerability to volatility spillover, making it an ideal candidate for portfolio diversification.
Asymmetric Spillover: The study identifies the presence of asymmetric volatility spillover, with positive and negative volatilities having differing impacts on the connected markets. The findings indicate that CADis the highest recipient of negative volatility spillover, while CADis the highest transmitter of positive volatility spillover. This asymmetry highlights the importance of considering both positive and negative market movements when assessing spillover effects.
These results emphasize Bitcoin's role as a valuable diversification tool, particularly in portfolios involving traditional currency markets. The findings also suggest that Bitcoin's market behavior is largely independent of traditional currency markets, reinforcing its potential as a hedge against market downturns.
Implications
The study’s findings suggest that Bitcoin’s unique market behavior could have significant implications for investors, policymakers, and financial institutions. For investors, Bitcoin’s low correlation with traditional currencies makes it a powerful tool for diversifying portfolios, especially in times of economic uncertainty. This could lead to increased demand for Bitcoin as a hedging asset, prompting more widespread adoption and potentially driving up its value. As a result, Bitcoin might become an essential component of global investment strategies, with institutional investors incorporating it into their portfolios to enhance returns and reduce risk. This growing demand could also lead to more mining activities, with potential technological advancements in the field to meet the increased need for Bitcoin.
For policymakers and financial institutions, the study highlights the need for careful consideration of Bitcoin’s impact on financial stability. The asymmetric spillover effects identified in the research suggest that Bitcoin could introduce new risks to traditional financial markets, particularly during periods of market stress. Policymakers may need to develop regulations that address these risks while still allowing for innovation and growth in the digital currency space. Financial institutions might also need to adapt their risk management practices to account for the unique characteristics of Bitcoin, ensuring that they are prepared for potential volatility and market shifts driven by this increasingly influential asset.
Issues
Market Isolation of EUR: The isolation of the EUR market from other foreign exchange pairs indicates that it can serve as a strong diversification tool, particularly for investors focused on the euro. This low correlation with other markets suggests that EUR can provide significant risk mitigation during market downturns, making it a valuable addition to portfolios seeking stability.
Asymmetric Spillover Effects: The study reveals that positive and negative volatilities have different impacts on market spillovers, particularly with Bitcoin's influence on traditional currency pairs. This asymmetry can pose a threat to investors who do not account for these differences in their risk management strategies, potentially leading to underestimation of risk during periods of market stress.
Dominance of Short-Term Spillovers: The finding that volatility spillovers are more pronounced in the short term presents an opportunity for investors to capitalize on short-term trading strategies. This dynamic suggests that timely market reactions to global events can enhance portfolio performance, particularly in environments where quick decision-making and real-time data analysis are crucial.
Currency-Specific Hedging Capabilities: Bitcoin's differing hedging capabilities across various currencies, such as its role as a hedge for the euro and British pound, presents an opportunity for tailored investment strategies. Investors can leverage Bitcoin's unique properties to hedge against specific currency risks, enhancing the robustness of their portfolios.
Minimal Influence of Bitcoin on CAD: The minimal volatility spillover from Bitcoin markets to the CAD pair suggests that CAD could be an excellent choice for portfolio diversification, particularly for those concerned about Bitcoin-induced volatility. This presents an opportunity to include CAD in portfolios as a stable counterbalance to Bitcoin's fluctuations.
Regulatory Considerations for Asymmetric Spillovers: The asymmetric nature of spillovers between Bitcoin and traditional currencies may lead to regulatory challenges. Policymakers may need to develop new frameworks to manage the unique risks posed by Bitcoin's market behavior, particularly in maintaining financial stability during periods of extreme volatility.
Risk of Inadequate Real-Time Monitoring: Given the dominance of short-term spillovers, there is a significant threat to investors who fail to implement adequate real-time monitoring systems. Without such systems, they may miss critical market movements, leading to potential losses or missed opportunities in highly volatile markets.
Technological Dependency in Bitcoin Markets: The study underscores the importance of technological advancements in the rapid transmission of information within Bitcoin markets. This dependency on technology presents a threat if investors or market participants do not have access to cutting-edge tools, potentially putting them at a disadvantage.
Potential Policy Backlash: The findings on Bitcoin's spillover effects could lead to increased scrutiny from policymakers, particularly if Bitcoin's market behavior is seen as a risk to broader financial stability. This could result in stricter regulations, potentially limiting the growth and adoption of Bitcoin as an investment asset.
Portfolio Optimization with Bitcoin: The ability of Bitcoin to act as both a hedge and a diversifier in different contexts offers a unique opportunity for portfolio optimization. Investors can strategically include Bitcoin in their portfolios to enhance returns while reducing overall risk, particularly in portfolios that include foreign exchange components.
Open Questions
Market Isolation of EUR
- How can the isolation of EURbe leveraged to optimize portfolio diversification strategies in different market conditions?
- What potential risks might arise from relying heavily on the EURmarket for diversification during extreme market events?
Asymmetric Spillover Effects
- What specific factors contribute to the asymmetric spillover effects between Bitcoin and traditional currency markets?
- How can investors adjust their risk management strategies to account for the differing impacts of positive and negative spillovers?
Dominance of Short-Term Spillovers
- What are the key drivers behind the short-term volatility spillovers observed in Bitcoin and foreign exchange markets?
- How can investors best capitalize on short-term spillovers while mitigating potential risks associated with rapid market movements?
Currency-Specific Hedging Capabilities
- What mechanisms underlie Bitcoin's varying hedging capabilities across different currencies, and how can these be predicted?How can investment strategies be tailored to maximize the hedging benefits of Bitcoin in portfolios containing specific currency exposures?
Minimal Influence of Bitcoin on CAD
- What factors contribute to the minimal influence of Bitcoin on the CAD pair, and how stable is this relationship over time?
- How can the CAD pair be effectively integrated into portfolios to counterbalance Bitcoin-induced volatility?
Regulatory Considerations for Asymmetric Spillovers
- What regulatory measures could be implemented to address the risks associated with asymmetric spillover effects in Bitcoin markets?
- How might future regulations impact the ability of Bitcoin to serve as a hedging instrument in global financial markets?
Risk of Inadequate Real-Time Monitoring
- What are the most effective real-time monitoring tools for tracking short-term spillovers in Bitcoin markets?
- How can organizations ensure that they are not at a disadvantage due to lagging technological capabilities in monitoring Bitcoin volatility?
Technological Dependency in Bitcoin Markets
- What technological innovations are most critical for maintaining a competitive edge in Bitcoin trading and portfolio management?
- How might technological disruptions impact the stability and behavior of Bitcoin markets, particularly in terms of spillover effects?
Potential Policy Backlash
- What scenarios could trigger a policy backlash against Bitcoin due to its spillover effects on traditional financial markets?
- How can the Bitcoin community and investors prepare for potential regulatory changes that could limit the growth of Bitcoin as an investment asset?
Portfolio Optimization with Bitcoin
- What strategies can be developed to optimize portfolios that include Bitcoin, particularly in volatile markets?
- How can Bitcoin's dual role as a hedge and diversifier be balanced to maximize portfolio returns while minimizing risk?
Five Key Research Needs
- Asymmetric Spillover Effects and Risk Management
Understanding the drivers of asymmetric spillover effects is crucial for developing robust risk management strategies. Since Bitcoin's market behavior can vary significantly based on the type of volatility (positive or negative), further research into the factors that cause this asymmetry will enhance investors' ability to mitigate risks during market turbulence. Insights from this research could lead to improved portfolio management practices, particularly in minimizing losses during periods of negative volatility spikes. - Regulatory Responses to Bitcoin's Market Influence
Given Bitcoin's growing impact on traditional financial markets, exploring potential regulatory frameworks that address the unique risks posed by asymmetric spillovers is essential. This research will be pivotal in guiding policymakers to create balanced regulations that safeguard financial stability without stifling innovation. Effective regulations based on this research could prevent systemic risks while allowing Bitcoin to continue its role as an innovative financial asset. - Optimization of Bitcoin in Currency-Specific Portfolios
The varying hedging capabilities of Bitcoin across different currencies present an opportunity to develop tailored investment strategies. Research in this area will help investors better understand how to utilize Bitcoin as a hedging tool, particularly in portfolios that are heavily exposed to specific currencies. This research could lead to more effective use of Bitcoin in global portfolios, enhancing returns while providing targeted risk mitigation. - Real-Time Monitoring and Technological Advancements
As short-term spillovers dominate Bitcoin markets, researching the most effective real-time monitoring tools is critical. Ensuring that investors and institutions can respond swiftly to market changes will help them maintain a competitive edge. Advancements in monitoring technology could reduce the risk of significant losses due to delayed responses, particularly in fast-moving markets where timing is essential. - Implications of Bitcoin's Market Isolation
The isolation of markets like EURsuggests unique opportunities and risks for portfolio diversification. Research into the stability of this isolation and its implications for long-term investment strategies will provide valuable insights for both individual and institutional investors. Understanding the potential benefits and pitfalls of relying on isolated markets could lead to more sophisticated portfolio diversification techniques, reducing overall portfolio risk.
(2) Implications for Bitcoin
Increased Demand for Bitcoin as a Diversification Tool
The study highlights Bitcoin's ability to serve as both a hedge and a diversifier in currency portfolios, particularly during times of financial instability. As more investors recognize these benefits, the demand for Bitcoin could rise, leading to increased mining activities to meet this demand. This surge in demand might incentivize more individuals and organizations to participate in Bitcoin mining, potentially accelerating technological advancements in mining efficiency and sustainability.
Regulatory Impacts on Bitcoin Adoption
The study's identification of asymmetric spillover effects and the potential risks associated with these effects could prompt stricter regulatory scrutiny of Bitcoin. If policymakers perceive Bitcoin's market behavior as a threat to financial stability, they may implement regulations that could either hinder or promote its adoption. For instance, regulations designed to mitigate risks could impose higher compliance costs on miners and investors, potentially slowing the growth of Bitcoin adoption. Conversely, clear regulatory frameworks that address these concerns might encourage broader acceptance and integration of Bitcoin into mainstream financial systems.
Enhanced Role of Bitcoin in Global Financial Portfolios
As the study suggests, Bitcoin's low level of integration with traditional currencies positions it as a valuable asset for portfolio diversification. This characteristic could lead to greater institutional adoption of Bitcoin, with large financial institutions incorporating it into their investment strategies. As Bitcoin becomes more ingrained in global financial portfolios, its role as a mainstream financial asset will solidify, potentially increasing its price stability and attractiveness as a store of value. This broader adoption could also drive innovation in Bitcoin-related financial products and services, further integrating Bitcoin into the global economy.
Technological Innovations Driven by Mining Needs
The dominance of short-term spillovers in Bitcoin markets, as noted in the study, underscores the importance of real-time monitoring and rapid response capabilities. For Bitcoin miners, this could translate into a need for more advanced and efficient mining technologies that can adapt quickly to market changes. The pressure to maintain a competitive edge in an increasingly dynamic market might spur innovations in mining hardware and software, as well as in energy-efficient practices, to reduce operational costs and environmental impact.
Impact on Long-Term Strategic Thinking
The potential for Bitcoin to act as a hedge against traditional currency risks might influence long-term strategic thinking among investors and policymakers. As Bitcoin adoption grows, its influence on monetary policy and economic planning could increase. Policymakers might need to consider Bitcoin's role in the broader financial ecosystem when making decisions about interest rates, inflation control, and economic stability. For investors, the ability to use Bitcoin as a tool for long-term wealth preservation could shift investment strategies, encouraging a more diversified and resilient approach to asset management.
Comments ()